As a college student, I am supposed to be focused on academic things, which I am. However, sometimes I throw more enthusiasm into my hobbies for the sake of my sanity. About a month ago I had been compiling a list of great things to bake, particularly for Halloween, but I did not have enough money or enough people to justify my yearnings. Enter "Wait Until Dark." My apartment complex was having a movie night, and I volunteered to be in charge of the goodies. My landlord gave me a budget, I researched and combined all the ingredients I would need, emailed them to my landlord, and voila! A few days later she and her husband showed up at my door with everything. (And I was well under budget.)
And what are not included on the table are 20 sticks of butter, 60 eggs, and 4 blocks of cream cheese. Yes, there was a heart attack in my fridge.
2 bags of snickers, 2 bags of m & ms, and 6 bags of chocolate chips. Note the jar with the yellow label: molasses. Never in my life had I encountered it until then. It's dark and gooey. It smells like sweet dirt. This may be an odd description, but if anyone is familiar with beets, especially sugar beets, then you'll know what I'm talking about.
Hello sugar and 6 boxes of cake mix...
I wish I had taken pictures while I was actually making all these things. Flour was all over the floor, not to mention my baking jeans (they're a size bigger than the rest of my jeans...they make it easier to move). Pictures never do the mess justice anyways; it's something that must be experienced. Moving on. I decided that I would tackle this project in phases. Wednesday night I began only making the doughs.
I made eight cookie doughs, and you probably cannot see my labels. Ergo, I will list them in not so great detail:
- Homemade oreos
- Pumpkin cookies
- Gingersnaps
- Checkerboard cookies
- Peanut butter cookies
- Sugar cookies
- Chocolate surprise
- Peanuts sitting pretty
I must admit I cheated a bit with the checkerboard ones. I already had them made a while ago and never got around to baking them. So, I thought this would be the perfect chance to use them. And don't worry, I'll explain what some of the other cookies are later.
Behold, the Tower of Madness.
After that was all finished on Wednesday night, I decided to paint my nails. Logical right? I just needed some down time, which is odd that I would choose to paint my nails. It used to bother me profusely. Only my toenails were acceptable to be painted, but recently fingernail painting has been growing on me. I'll never figure myself out. I promise they match my sweater so much better in real life than in the still.
This is what my kitchen sink looked like on Thursday after everything was baked minus the oreos and peanuts sitting pretty. In my defense, my roommate was making a fancy dinner for her fiancé that night. Notice the pots, pans, and plates that support my argument.
That night I went to sleep at 2am. I got chocolate on my bed sheets that had smeared off some part of my body or clothing because, yes, I was too exhausted to worry about pajamas that night. When I woke up on Friday and put on my glasses, I couldn't figure out why I could not see very well. After closer examination I realized there was flour all over the lenses.
So Friday was the big day. The rest of the cookies needed to be baked, and all the frosting needed to happen. Plus, they needed to be wrapped and carried down to the serving tables. This is the empty bowl of cream cheese frosting that my friends help me to clear. (I just couldn't frost all those cookies alone.)
The sugar cookies were the biggest and the baddest. I decided that since the Halloween pack came with four different cutouts, then I would make four different shaped cookies. Here are the pumpkin ones, coming in at a count of 40. Next are the ghost cookies: 39. I must say that their tails were quite annoying.
And finally we have the cats and half moons: 32 and 35 respectively. The sugar cookies gave me the most pain because they cook so quickly and I would get carried away with cutting out the next batch for the oven. Oh, and how convenient, I discovered that my oven really has no chance of cooking anything on the bottom rack without giving it a dose of fibrous charcoal. Fortunately, I caught all the cookies before they reached that point.

Oreos. 75 oreos x 2 = 150 chocolate cookies baked to make them. These were the favorites of the night. I didn't even taste one because they were gone right when I opened the plastic. Actually, thanks to an impatient roommate, they started disappearing before I officially opened them.
The checkerboard cookies (65) were adorable, but did not live up to the taste I wanted them to have. I think they could be greatly improved by covering the bottoms in chocolate. Next time I suppose.
These are the peanuts sitting pretty (61). Basically they are a kind of cookie rolled in walnuts with vanilla frosting and m & ms on top. The m & ms are supposed to be peanut, but the Halloween colors were more of a must, therefore these are plain chocolate m & ms.
These are all the cookies sitting in my living room. Unfortunately it does not look like that total it came out to. Mind you there are plates stacked on one another. I did not find it obligatory to take pictures of the pumpkin cookies, gingersnaps, or chocolate surprises because they look normal. But to explain what the chocolate surprises are is just basically a chocolate cookie with a fun size snickers smashed inside of it. They are deadly and very chocolately.
So, I think we should add all these up:
- Pumpkin = 40
- Gingersnaps = 50
- Chocolate surprises = 57
- Peanut butter = 50
- Oh, and I made one special cookie out of the extra sugar cookie dough I had. It was Voldemort = 1.
This brings us to a grand total of approximately 620 cookies. I am now curtsying for your mental applause. The best part of the night was that everything was well received, which I was rather worried about. I was quite lucky. Nothing was too hard, burnt, or flat out disgusting.
I was left with a somewhat generous amount of leftovers. I was able to give most of them away. I was content with having a plate of pumpkin cookies and gingersnaps. They were quite addicting. They just don't taste as sugary as the other ones did and therefore made me feel that my consumption was not as gluttonous. I'm sure my body will figure out down the road that this is not the case. Until then "Bon Appétit!"